As self-admitted night owls, we know how convenient disposable makeup wipes can be. If you can relate, switching to reusable makeup remover pads might seem more like a sacrifice than a logical move. But by seeing how the clean-beauty movement has influenced the way so many people stock their makeup kits with more sustainable, thoughtful products, we've also observed the smart options brands have invented for removing that makeup. Makeup remover cloths and reusable cotton pads aren't just more eco-friendly (by helping cut back on landfill waste caused by disposable cotton rounds and makeup wipes), they're also a more affordable option. While a microfiber towel or washable round might initially cost more than a pack of single-use wipes, you'll also be able to use them for months—or years.
Within the reusable category, there are a few ways to go. Whether you want a cloth that simply activates with warm water or one you can pair with your favorite toners and micellar waters, there's a machine-washable solution. Then there are shapes: Do you prefer a something that resembles a cotton round, or is it easier to use a washcloth-sized microfiber remover? We rounded up the 10 best reusable makeup remover pads on the internet, as evidenced by thousands of five-star rave reviews. Below, take your pick of sustainable ways to melt off every last trace of waterproof mascara.
Reviews have been edited and condensed for clarity.
1/10
Original Pink MakeUp Eraser
Star rating: 4.8 out of 5
Key selling points: A supersoft towel that gets everything off and can be thrown in the wash. Reviewers love the durability (three to five years) and how thoroughly it cleanses with the sole addition of warm water.
What shoppers say: “I love this product! I run it under hot water and wring excess water out, then hold it over eyes for 30-45 seconds to loosen mascara. Then, I wipe my eyes and face clean. When I use my toner with disposable wipes, I still get excess makeup residue on cotton rounds, but not after using this eraser. I rinse out the eraser with warm water and occasionally soap, and hang to dry. I will use it for a couple days, then throw in the washer and dryer with towels. You can use regular detergent and fabric softener. It saves a lot of money on wipes. I bought several colors and rotate them out every two to three days!” —Lisa L, reviewer on Ulta
2/10
The Organic Pharmacy Organic Muslin Cloth
Star rating: 5 out of 5
Key selling points: Muslin cloths have the added benefit of providing gentle physical exfoliation, leaving your skin with a post-removal glow. For best results, pair these with a cleansing balm that will moisturize skin while melting away all traces of makeup.
What shoppers say: “It seems like a such a simple step, but this makes the world of a difference when cleansing. I use it every other day with my Vanicream cleanser and my skin feels so soft and smooth after! It exfoliates so gently it doesn’t irritate my sensitive skin. Every single physical exfoliator I’ve used has been too abrasive, but this is so perfect! You definitely see that post-facial glow.” —S.S., reviewer on Dermstore
